iM1 review – Korg do their very best to top Gadget and Module with mega-synth app for iOS

Download from iTunes App StoreiM1 logoI’ve been lucky enough to review some absolutely brilliant iOS synth apps here on the music app blog over the last few years and a number of these will, undoubtedly, be firm favourites of many regular readers here as well as myself. However, last week saw two new contenders for the ‘best iOS synth ever’ shortlist; SynthMaster Player and iM1.

I reviewed SynthMaster Player last week and, at what it does – giving the user access to some awesome sounds with just enough editing options to keep things interesting – it is a phenomenal app. The collection of sounds is hugely impressive and you can add to the 800 or so available for the initial UK£3.99 ‘pro upgrade’ IAP with a huge number of further IAP options if you wish.

The second of these two apps – iM1 – is Korg’s latest iOS music app. Now, Korg set the bar pretty high for themselves (and their competitors) last year by releasing two apps – Gadget and Module – that easily made my top ten list of new apps in 2014. If Korg to eventually get around to adding audio recording into the gadget environment, as Module’s excellent sample-based sounds can be accessed from within it, it would become a very good bet as a complete production environment for the iOS musician.

So, no pressure then with the release of iM1…. :-)

iM1 in 'easy' mode. This is easy to use but, don't be fooled, as this app has plenty of depth if you want to dive in.

iM1 in ‘easy’ mode. This is easy to use but, don’t be fooled, as this app has plenty of depth if you want to dive in.

As can be guessed from the name, iM1 is a virtual recreation of Korg’s classic hardware synth from the late 1980s – M1 – and that became an almost instant ‘classic’. If you have listened to any amount of music made since that time then the odds are you are already very familiar with how the M1 sounds. It has been used by almost everyone and his dog and appeared on countless hit recordings.

In the form of an iOS music app, Korg claim to have faithfully reproduced the sound and functionality of the original hardware. However, this is not a slavish reproduction and, where appropriate, Korg have been sensible enough to add some ‘extras’ into this software version. This includes more filter options, more flexible effects options and the inclusion of some novel performance options such as the virtual Kaoss pad. iM1 is, therefore, a recreation of the M1 with bells on.

The various other screens provide all the programming options you need for tweaking your own sounds.

The various other screens provide all the programming options you need for tweaking your own sounds.

Mmmmmm

What about some iM1 basics? Well, the app is currently available for UK£14.99 (this is a ‘launch’ discounted price 33% off what will be the eventual price) and, if you like what you hear, then you can also purchase two further IAPs (UK£3.99 each) that provide a huge number of further preset sounds that were originally available as expansion cards for the hardware synth. In total, with the base app and the two IAPs, you end up with over 3300 individual presets.

The app requires iOS8.0 or later and runs on an iPad. Given that this is not intended to be some stripped down synth, yes, the newer the hardware you try to run it on, the better, although Korg suggest it will run on an iPad 2 or newer. The app is a 90MB download.

The app includes Audiobus and IAA support. MIDI support is also pretty comprehensive and I had no problems using the app with an external keyboard. As with Module, however, you can also use the iM1 within Gadget. Here it appears as a new ‘gadget’ called Darwin and, while you get access to all your sounds, you don’t get quite the same level of sound editing as in the stand-alone app. You do, however, get to use multiple instances of Darwin within your Gadget projects.

iM1 offers a 'Multi' mode where you get eight part multi-timbral operation and can configure programs, effects, and various MIDI settings on a per-part basis.

iM1 offers a ‘Multi’ mode where you get eight part multi-timbral operation and can configure programs, effects, and various MIDI settings on a per-part basis.

That said, iM1 itself is also multi-timbral. Indeed, you can flip between three ‘modes’ – Prog, Combi and Multi – using the buttons located top-right of the main interface. Prog allows you to work with a single sound (program). However, Combi allows you to later up to eight sounds into a single ‘mega-sound’ while Multi gives you eight separate sounds that can operate on different MIDI channels. Used with a suitable DAW/sequencer, you could, therefore, use iM1 as your only sound source and still create a pretty full-on musical arrangement.

Start the engine

Korg’s M1 was originally released in 1988 and it is estimated that around 250,000 units were manufactured during a six year period. The synth was a huge success and this was mainly because of the high quality of the sound. This was built on an engine that combined both samples and synthesis (S & S), where subtractive synthesis was applied to complex digital samples (rather than simple analog waveforms).

Individual programs (sounds) in the iM1 follow a similar strategy and, like the original hardware, can use one or two of these ‘oscillators’ to built a sound. The sound is then passed onwards and processed through a filter (and here the iM1 scores over the original as it includes a resonant filter rather than just a low-pass variety), an amplifier stage, options for sound modulation, real-time sound control (again, the virtual Kaoss pads of the iM1 add an extra element here) and a whole range of effects choices including both insert and master (send) effects.

iM1's filter options are more sophisticated than on the original hardware synth.

iM1’s filter options are more sophisticated than on the original hardware synth.

As shown by the various screenshots included here, if you want to dig into sound construction, iM1 offers you plenty of opportunities to do so, with separate screens for the Osc, VDF (filter), VDA (amplifier), Control and Insert FX (you can have two insert effects per program), if you prefer an easier life, you can also use the Easy screen. This is a great move by Korg; it provides a single screen with the key controls from all the other editing screen presented in a concise format. Giving uses the choice between scratching at the surface or digging deeper means the iM1 ought to appeal to almost any keen synth users, whether they have a PhD in synthesis or not.

The app also includes well-specified amplifier envelope features.

The app also includes well-specified amplifier envelope features.

All that said, within each section of the synth engine, if you do decide to dig in, then there is plenty to keep the power user happy. I’ll not pretend to have got my own head around all the options in the short time I’ve had to work with the app so far but the options are considerable. For example, take the VDF page… here you get separate filters for each oscillator, modulation generators for each filter and the ability to use both velocity and keyboard tracked control of the filter’s response.

There are plenty of real-time control options available with iM1.

There are plenty of real-time control options available with iM1.

And if this all starts to make your head spin, then you can consult the excellent built-in PDF manual. This provides a fairly concise summary of the iM1’s key controls but also refers you on to the original M1 manual (you can get this ion PDF format from Korg’s website); the fact that the M1 documentation is relevant does suggest that the app and the original hardware really do work in very similar fashions.

Listen to it purr

So what kind of sound does the engine make once you have it started? Well, set aside a couple of hours, hook up an external keyboard, and flick through a decent crop of the included presets… which is exactly what I did and I have to say it was just a complete pleasure. If I had to pick one word to describe how the iM1 sounds then it would be ‘classy’.

Yes, there are perhaps times when the ‘late 80s’ nature of the sounds come through (although that’s not necessarily a bad thing) and you perhaps have to do your own tweaking if you want to coax something uber-aggressive out of the iM1 that might rip the face off punters on the dance floor (the distortion and overdrive effects can help here!) but, as a broad collection of synth-based sounds going from piano to pad and with almost every stop in between covered, the iM1 is massively impressive.

Just how many presets do you need? iM1, with both IAPs, is seriously well stocked with sounds.

Just how many presets do you need? iM1, with both IAPs, is seriously well stocked with sounds.

Some of the piano and organ sounds I’m sure I can recall from specific house or techno tracks but, as the user list of the original M1 reads like a ‘who’s who’ of pop and rock for the last 20 years, it would be quite surprising if you didn’t listen to a few of the presets and have a ‘that’s the sounds from….’ moment or three. Does it sound exactly like the original? OK, so I’ve never played a hardware M1 but, frankly, I’m not sure if I care wither the iM1 nails it to perfection; it simply sound great in its own right.

Having purchased both of the IAPs, it is actually hard to know where to start with summing up the presets in any concise fashion – there are simply too many of them to do that – but there are some really useable synth bass sounds within the collection and that would provide a solid foundation for any electronic based track. Equally, the selection of organ sounds is just fabulous and spans everything from pipe organs through to dance-friendly sounds that you can bash out ‘housey’ chord sequences on.

The app offers plenty of effects options both as insert effects (applied to an individual program) and two 'master FX'.

The app offers plenty of effects options both as insert effects (applied to an individual program) and two ‘master FX’.

The selection of pianos is just as good and, again, there are sounds here that will seem familiar from commercial recordings. Oh, and don’t forget the drums or the pads or the brass or the synth leads or…. well, you get the idea. This is a huge palette of sounds and, while you might easily identify other synths that you might have sitting alongside iM1 to plug the occasional sound gap or give you something more obviously intended for experimental electronica, for a one-stop, multi-timbral, synth-based sound source, iM1 (like SynthMaster Player) is a very impressive option.

And it must also be said that the preset browsing and searching options are very good. You can browse the presets via instrument type, any of the preset ‘cards’ (the original add-on cards for the hardware M1) of by mood (dark, fast, slow, fat, etc.). Given the total number of presets available if you have opted for the extra IAPs, this browsing system is both welcome and well implemented.

All play nicely

Talking of multi-timbral, the fact that iM1 can operate as an eight-part sound source makes that ‘one-stop-shop’ tag all the more do-able. I had no problems setting up multiple MIDI tracks within Cubasis and feeding these to iM1. On my iPad Air 1 test system, this all worked very smoothly.

There are a number of other ‘performance’ features that are worthy of note. For example, while using the Multi or Combi options, selecting the Perform screen gives to a whole screen full of horizontal sliders for a small selection of parameters… but available for each of the eight possible sounds. You can, therefore, easily tweak these without flipping back and forth between different programs, whether that’s just at the sound editing stage or during a performance.

iM1's real-time control options are pretty comprehensive including the Kaoss pads.

iM1’s real-time control options are pretty comprehensive including the Kaoss pads.

Equally, the MIDI screen allows you to configure how each of the eight sounds responds to MIDI in terms of channel, MIDI notes and velocity. Whether you want to create keyboard splits or layers sounds, you have all the control required here. Given this level of control, iM1 could easily make a great choice for live performance.

Oh, and if you add in the Master FX options here… where this screen allows you to configure the two master FX choices and adjust the sends from each of the eight parts to those two effects – you will soon appreciate just how much the iM1 offers in terms of effects. Compared to the original hardware, you get far more choice and flexibility – from reverbs to exciters and from delays through to distortion – iM1 has it covered and you also get plenty of controls for each effect.

Oh, and a further thing….  don’t forget the virtual keyboard, the options to set that to particular scales, a further options for triggering chords and the rather wonderful X-Y Kaoss pads that can be used for both sound shaping and note generation (in a rather Figure-like fashion).

The virtual keyboard offers both scales (shown here) and chord options.

The virtual keyboard offers both scales (shown here) and chord options.

In use

Korg are now pretty experienced when it comes to coding for iOS and I didn’t expect there to be any specific issues in using iM1 with Audiobus or IAA… or, indeed, within Gadget. No surprises then that, in my testing at least, all seemed to run very smoothly. I suspect the biggest issues users are likely to find is that iM1 – with it’s eight parts all playing multiple notes – is likely to give earlier iOS hardware a bit of a through workout. Combine it with a few other apps and things and your iPad might get a bit cranky. That said, I ran multiple parts into a fairly busy Cubasis project without any problems.

I was easily able to send multiple channels of MIDI data to iM1 for playback.

I was easily able to send multiple channels of MIDI data to iM1 for playback.

Used within Gadget, you still get access to all those wonderful presets. This is great… but there is a bit of a trade-off; you swap the option for multiple instances of Darwin (iM1’s ‘Gadget’ name) with a somewhat more restricted set of editing options for your sounds. This is not such a big deal as you can always do all your sound editing in the stand-alone app… If you are a regular Gadget users, then I think iM1 is, frankly, a bit of a no-brainer; it’s a great add-on to the existing gadgets and the sample-based sounds offered by Module.

Used within Gadget, you get fewer sound editing options, but you can use multiple instances of 'Darwin (iM1) if required and all the presets are available.

Used within Gadget, you get fewer sound editing options, but you can use multiple instances of ‘Darwin (iM1) if required and all the presets are available.

So many synths?

OK, so I think you will already have got the idea that I’m impressed by Korg’s iM1. Like with Gadget and Module, Korg have delivered something that is right up there with the very best that iOS currently has to offer. There is a difference with iM1 though….   it is entering a music app category – virtual synths – that is perhaps more densely populated that that of the ‘electronic music production environment’ or ‘virtual instrument’ categories; the competition is, therefore, somewhat stiffer.

I own more iOS synths then I can possibly ever fully use but, like most iOS musicians, I have a smaller collection of ‘go to’ synths that I use on a regular basis. I’ve recently added SynthMaster Player to that list and now I’m going to add iM1 also. Something might drop off the list as a consequence… but iM1 is hugely impressive – technically and sonically – and I’m sure is going to get a lot of use in my own iOS music making.

iM1 seemed to work very smoothly via Audiobus or IAA.

iM1 seemed to work very smoothly via Audiobus or IAA.

SynthMaster and iM1 make for an interesting comparison however. Both offer large collections of preset sounds and, if you just like to load a sound and get on with music making, both can offer the user that experience. However, for the more geeky tone-editor types, iM1 wins hands down in terms of the editing options. In contrast, I think SynthMaster Player actually includes some sounds – perhaps more at the cutting edge of electronic dance music – that iM1 doesn’t (will, not in terms of the supplied presets anyway) cover quite so well. Together, however, they make for a pretty awesome combination.

In summary

If you are a confirmed iOS synth-head, then I suspect you may already have done the deed and have purchased iM1. If you have not, then temptation may just eat at you until you give in and do it anyway. If that sounds likely, then do it while the launch pricing is still available – UK£14.99 is just a bit silly given quite how good iM1 sounds and plays – and while you are at it, budget for those IAPs as well.

For the newbie iOS musician who is still building up their iOS music app collection, iM1 would make a brilliant choice for a collection of high-quality synth sounds and, because it gives you eight-part multi-timbral operation, you could easily put together projects where this was your only sound source.

Korg’s iM1 might not be the only iOS synth that you ever need but, as with Gadget and Module, it is a very impressive app. Highly recommended for almost any iOS musician who uses synth-based sounds. This is top-notch stuff from Korg and I can only imagine users lapping it up….  and don’t forget that both Module and Gadget are still on sale…  This is not a good time for those with a genuine iOS music app addiction :-)

Korg iM1



Korg Module for iPad



Gadget




Check out Tim Webb’s ‘Let’s Play’ video on iM1 for an introduction to the synth engine.

Be Sociable; share this post....

    Comments

    1. Chris Catalano says:

      I loved this thing the instant I heard the first sound out of it. Restored a little of the faith that had a waned in me a little when the disappointing “Sampling” Gadgets took my money, but not my heart. If they get the Audio thing together, even as a closed environment Gadget becomes a full on monster…

      Imagine if there were multiple tracks in it with IAA support for FX and external Synths! I am not betting on that last part of that equation but I can dream. This stuff is truly in another league, and the iM1 went straight into the top layer of my iPad Synth Folder…

    2. Erik Lindblom says:

      very nice review!
      Keep up the good work John!
      IM1 is da shit!

    3. Hi Chris/Erik…. agreed – iM1 is an impressive bit of software. Here’s hoping Korg can deliver audio in Gadget at some stage :-) best wishes, John

    4. Hello John, I was hoping that once did a review, and so was :-)
      Also I find this app interesting, but for me the problem currently remains the same for every app that comes out: will it work on iPad 2?
      In this regard, I did not understand very well your opinion.
      I think, and I fear that on my ipad2 will be limited to some prog, or almost any combination, as I see it hard to multi … perhaps using the simplest sounds. What do you think? Hello and thanks for the great job.
      René

      • Hi Rene…. The App Store description suggests it will run on iPad 2 but with reduced polyphony…. I’ve an iPad 2 sitting here so I’ll give it a try later if I get a few minutes and report back… best wishes, John

        • Hi Rene… I did give this a bit of a try on my iPad 2… As a stand-alone app, iM1 actually seemed to run OK, including with some Multi patches using 3 or 4 parts. In that context, it didn’t seem too bad… I’ll see if I can give it a try with a few other things running alongside and just how far it can be pushed before things get a bit strained…. best wishes, John

    5. With iM1, Korg now has half of their entire Korg Legacy Collection (KLC) now on iPad. For iOS we have a version of the MS20, Polysix, and M1. if they decide to complete their KLC on iPad then we’d see the Mono/Poly, Wavestation, and maybe most needed (for Gadget) is the MDE-X, multi-effect plugin.

      John, since app pricing is a big subject with you, I wanted to point out that the desktop versions of these KLC synths (MS20, Polysix, M1, Wavestation) are each $49.99, while the full retail at the App Store for iPolysix and iMS20 were both at $29.99. I was curious about your thoughts on this. It’s a narrower gap than I would have thought.

      Hats off to Korg…what an outstanding job the’ve done done on iOS!

      U.S. Link for KLC
      http://www.korg.com/us/products/software/korg_legacy_collection/

    6. I am actually disappointed in the pricing with this. You have to buy the app and then purchase the addon packs. When you buy the desktop version all the cards come with it.

      I realize the argument can always be made that app prices are cheaper…but its all relative. Compared to a good percentage of the app market these are high priced. Yep cheaper than the hardware, etc etc. I know all the arguments. I purchased gadget but have yet to use it in a track. Same with a couple other synths but when you spend 5 bucks its a lot easier to not use it.

      Of course after a while those 5 and 10 dollar purchases add up.

      haha and with all that said I will probably pick up M1 at some point. Its ALWAYS been a favorite synth of mine so the chance to have another soft version will eventually draw me in :)

    7. Very well written as always. I was very happy to see the ability to control the voices on different midi channels. There are very few apps that can do that, while apps like Gestrument and Different Drumner just beg to run half a dozen synths.

    8. Chris Catalano says:

      Do you cover a lot of midi stuff in your book, Clif? Drives me a little nuts, so I tend to keep thinks simple in that area. Any chance of that being ported over to the iBook store? Kindles are something I have been considering because…easy on the eyes.

    9. David Abraham says:

      They also just fixed the expansion card issue that some were having. iM1+Gadget simply rocks.

    10. Dan MacGregor says:

      I just bought a Korg MicroKey 25 (my first MIDI controller!) and going to buy iM1 now. After reading your review I’m really excited!

    11. airmanchairman says:

      Well done, Korg.

      At present I have iMS-20 and Module.
      iWavestation would nicely complement the formidable app stable they’ve built so far.

    12. Yoed Yahav says:

      John, thank you for this great review!
      This app sounds and looks great!
      (I hope to be one of these lucky names drawn from your hat :-) )

    13. I’m seriously considering purchasing im1 for live gigging, but I have one question: how do the sounds hold up when playing live? I’m specifically interested in the string sounds which I will be using 95% of the time. I still haven’t found some appropriate soft, pop music style strings in any app at all (everything in the app store is orchestral) but I think im1 might be able to cover that. Are they good enough?

    14. Hello a newcomer to iOS and iM1 . I wondered if anyone can recommend midi controller keyboard say mini 37 key. I am leaning towards Korg micro key but at end someone knows a non Korg that is compatible and better ?.
      Thanks

    15. Last post mistake
      Should say but maybe someone knows ….. etc

    Speak Your Mind

    *